Lady Gaga As Scáthach

Lady Gaga isn’t one to shy away from risky choices, whether in her outfits, music, or the roles she picks. So, while freaky, seeing the Stupid Love singer all made up as the witch Scathach on American Horror Story: Roanoke is pretty much on-brand for her.

The A Star is Born actress, who’s known for getting involved in the characters she plays, brought her own makeup artist and hairdresser to help her pull off the dark and dirty look. Of course, show creator Ryan Murphy also gets credit for providing them with the inspiration for what the original Supreme should look like.